SEOExplainer

What a website SEO audit checks and what good looks like

The six areas every website SEO audit covers, the warning signs in each, and the benchmark a healthy site should meet.

  • By boompow Creative Studio
  • Updated 
  • 9 min read
What good looks like in an audit
FeatureHealthy siteNeeds work
IndexingEvery key page indexedPages excluded or noindexed
SpeedPasses Core Web VitalsLCP over 4 seconds on mobile
TitlesUnique and descriptiveDuplicated or missing
ContentOne page per topicThin or overlapping pages
LinksEarned from relevant sitesFew, or paid and irrelevant
Website SEO Audit: What It Checks and What Good Looks Like
On this page Book a free call

Short answer

A website SEO audit is a structured review of how well search engines can find, understand and trust your site. It covers six areas: crawling and indexing, technical health and speed, on-page signals, content quality, links and authority, and local and AI search visibility. Each finding is ranked by impact, so the problems costing you the most traffic get fixed first. Run a full audit at least once a year and before and after any redesign.

Key takeaways

  • An audit answers three questions: can Google reach your pages, does it understand them, and does it trust them enough to rank them?
  • Google Search Console is the starting point, because it shows how Google actually sees your site rather than how a third-party tool guesses it does.
  • Most findings fall into a few familiar groups: pages missing from Google, slow templates, duplicated titles, and thin or overlapping content.
  • A useful audit ends with a ranked fix list in plain language, not a score from a free checker.

An SEO audit is a health check for search. It looks at your site the way Google does, finds what stops pages from ranking and puts the fixes in order of impact. This guide explains what each part of an audit examines and what a healthy result looks like, so you can read any audit report and tell whether it covers the ground.

Want a hands-on list to work through yourself? Use our DIY 15-point SEO audit. To see how an agency runs the work from start to finish, read what a professional SEO audit covers.

What is a website SEO audit?

A website SEO audit is a structured review of everything that affects how your site ranks: whether Google can crawl and index your pages, how fast and stable they are, how clearly each page states its topic, how good the content is and how far other sites trust yours. It is the diagnostic step of search engine optimisation. The audit finds the problems; the SEO work that follows fixes them.

What it answers
Can Google reach your pages, does it understand them, and does it trust them enough to rank them above competitors?
What it produces
A list of findings, each with the evidence, the likely effect on traffic and the fix, ranked so the biggest problems come first.
What it isn’t
A score from a free checker. Tools report hundreds of warnings; an audit decides which of them matter for your business.

An SEO audit looks at search. A full website audit goes further, into usability, conversion and security. Many businesses need both, but they answer different questions.

When does a website need an SEO audit?

A website needs an SEO audit when search traffic falls without an obvious reason, before and after any major change to the site, and once a year as routine maintenance. These are the most common triggers.

  • Traffic has dropped: clicks in the Google Search Console Performance report are down on the same period last year, and the cause isn’t seasonal.
  • New pages aren’t showing up: pages you published weeks ago still don’t appear in Google, or appear only for your brand name.
  • A redesign or platform change is coming: this is the riskiest moment for rankings, and our website migration SEO checklist covers it step by step.
  • Competitors have pulled ahead: businesses you used to outrank now sit above you for your main services.
  • You’re about to hire an SEO provider: an audit sets the baseline and the plan, so you can judge progress later.
  • It’s been more than a year: plugins, content and Google’s own features change, and small problems pile up.

If a competitor is the issue, our guide to why a competitor is outranking you on Google explains the usual reasons.

Crawling and indexing: can Google reach your pages?

Crawling and indexing come first because a page Google hasn’t indexed cannot rank, however good it is. The audit checks that search engines can reach every page you want found, and stay out of the ones you don’t.

What the audit checks

  • The robots.txt file, for rules that block important pages, scripts or stylesheets.
  • Stray noindex tags, often left behind from a staging site or switched on by a plugin.
  • The XML sitemap: it should list only live, indexable pages and be submitted in Search Console.
  • Canonical tags, which tell Google which version of a page is the main one.
  • Server errors, redirect chains and internal links that lead to a 404 page.

What good looks like

In the Page indexing report in Google Search Console, every page you care about is indexed. Pages listed as “Not indexed” are there for a reason you chose, such as a redirect, a deliberate noindex or a duplicate with the right canonical. A site:yourdomain.com search gives a rough picture, but it isn’t a complete count, so rely on Search Console for the real numbers.

Technical health and page speed

Technical health means the site loads quickly, stays stable while it loads, works on a phone and is served securely over HTTPS. Google indexes the mobile version of your pages, so the phone experience is the one that counts.

Speed is measured with Google’s Core Web Vitals, three metrics based on real visits from Chrome users. A page passes when at least 75% of visits meet the “good” threshold.

MetricWhat it measuresGoodPoor
Largest Contentful Paint (LCP)How quickly the main content appears2.5 s or lessOver 4 s
Interaction to Next Paint (INP)How quickly the page responds to taps and clicks200 ms or lessOver 500 ms
Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS)How much the layout jumps while loading0.1 or lessOver 0.25

Test pages in PageSpeed Insights, which shows real-user field data where Google has enough of it and a Lighthouse lab test for any page. Google retired its separate Mobile-Friendly Test in December 2023, so mobile checks now happen in Lighthouse, in Chrome DevTools and, simplest of all, on your own phone.

If speed is the main problem on an online store, our guide to speeding up a WooCommerce website covers the usual fixes.

Lighthouse report
97Performance
99Accessibility
100Best practices
100SEO

0–49 50–89 90–100

Example Lighthouse scores before and after the fixes in this guide. Illustrative numbers; switch between Before and After.

On-page signals: titles, headings and structured data

On-page signals tell Google what each page is about. The audit checks them page by page, usually with a crawler that pulls every title, description and heading into one sheet.

  • Title tags: unique on every page, led by the main topic, and short enough to show in full in search results.
  • Meta descriptions: unique and written to earn the click. Google sometimes writes its own snippet, but it often uses a description that matches the page well.
  • Headings: one H1 that states the page topic, with H2s and H3s in a logical order.
  • Internal links: important pages are linked from related pages with descriptive anchor text, and none are buried many clicks from the home page.
  • Images: descriptive file names and alt text, and files compressed to a sensible size.
  • Structured data: valid schema markup for the business, articles, products or breadcrumbs, tested in the Rich Results Test.

Structured data changes faster than most areas. Google stopped showing FAQ rich results in May 2026, for example, so FAQ markup no longer earns expandable questions in search results. A current audit checks markup against Google’s structured data search gallery, not against advice from a few years ago.

Content quality and search intent

Content quality is whether each page gives searchers what they came for, better than the pages ranking above it. Google’s guidance on helpful, people-first content is the benchmark most audits use.

What the audit checks

  • Keyword mapping: each important search term has one page that targets it. When two pages chase the same term they compete with each other, which is called keyword cannibalisation.
  • Search intent: a page targeting “website redesign cost” should show prices, not a general sales pitch.
  • Thin and outdated pages: short pages that answer nothing, old posts with wrong prices or dates, and near-identical location pages.
  • Content gaps: questions your customers ask that no page on the site answers.

What good looks like

Every service has its own page, every page has a clear job, and the Search Console Performance report shows each page ranking for the terms it was written for. Pages with plenty of impressions but few clicks usually need a better title, a better answer or both.

Links and authority: does Google trust the site?

Authority is how far the rest of the web vouches for your site, and links from relevant, reputable websites are the clearest signal of it. The audit looks at who links to you, which pages they link to and whether any links put the site at risk.

  • The Links report in Search Console lists your top linking sites and most-linked pages, free.
  • Third-party tools such as Ahrefs or Semrush add competitor comparisons and link history.
  • Links pointing at pages that now return a 404 are wasted; redirecting those URLs recovers their value.
  • Paid links, link swaps and sudden bursts of irrelevant links count as link spam under Google’s spam policies.

Good looks like a steady set of links from sites in your industry and area: suppliers, partners, associations and local press. Our guide to link building explains how to earn more of them.

Local and AI search visibility

Local visibility decides whether you appear in map results for searches near you. AI visibility decides whether Google AI Overviews and other AI tools draw on your pages when they answer questions. Both now belong in an SEO audit.

Local search

The audit checks that your Google Business Profile is claimed and complete, that your business name, address and phone number match across the profile, your site and directories, and that new reviews keep arriving and get replies.

AI answers

Google says there are no extra requirements for appearing in AI Overviews or AI Mode: a page has to be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet, as in normal search (see Google’s guidance on AI features). So the audit checks what makes content easy to quote: a direct answer near the top of each page, plain definitions, clear headings, and facts such as prices and service areas written as text rather than locked inside images.

How to judge a website SEO audit report

A useful audit report ranks findings by impact, explains each one in plain language and says who should fix it. This is the order most findings should be tackled in.

  1. Important pages are blocked, noindexed or missing from Google Fix immediately
  2. Key templates fail Core Web Vitals or break on mobile Fix this month
  3. Titles, headings or internal links are weak on key pages Next round of edits
  4. Content gaps, thin pages or overlapping posts Plan into the content calendar
  5. Few links from relevant sites Ongoing work

Be sceptical of any report that is only a list of tool warnings, marks every issue as critical, or promises a top ranking. Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO is direct: no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. If you’d rather have the audit and the fixes done for you, see our SEO services.

SEO, AEO & GEOSee how we get you found on Google and in AI answers

Website SEO audit questions

What is a website SEO audit?

A website SEO audit is a structured review of how well search engines can crawl, understand and trust your site. It covers indexing, technical health and speed, on-page signals, content quality, links, and local and AI visibility, and it ends with a prioritised list of fixes.

How often should I audit my website for SEO?

Run a full SEO audit at least once a year, and always before and after a redesign, platform change or domain move. Between audits, check Google Search Console every month for indexing errors, Core Web Vitals problems and falls in clicks.

What tools are used for an SEO audit?

Most SEO audits start with Google Search Console and PageSpeed Insights, which are free. A crawler such as Screaming Frog SEO Spider collects titles, headings, links and status codes for every page, and tools such as Ahrefs or Semrush add backlink and competitor data.

What is the difference between an SEO audit and a website audit?

An SEO audit checks how a site performs in search: indexing, speed, on-page signals, content and links. A website audit covers SEO plus usability, accessibility, conversion, security and maintenance, so it asks whether the whole site does its job for visitors and for the business.

Can I audit my own website for SEO?

Yes, for the basics. A business owner can check indexing, speed, titles, headings and Google Business Profile with free tools. Deeper issues such as redirect chains, canonical conflicts, JavaScript rendering or a sudden traffic drop are usually faster to solve with a specialist.

Will an SEO audit improve my rankings on its own?

No. An SEO audit shows what to fix, and rankings improve once the fixes are made and Google has recrawled the pages. Be wary of anyone who promises a specific position, because Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking.

Does an SEO audit cover Google AI Overviews?

A current SEO audit should. Google says pages need no special optimisation for AI Overviews beyond being indexed and eligible to show a snippet, so the audit checks indexing, direct answers near the top of pages, plain definitions and key facts written as text.

About the authors

boompow Creative Studio

Written and reviewed by our team of designers, developers and SEO specialists, with more than 40 years of combined digital marketing experience. We’re based in Cape Town, Johannesburg and London and work with clients worldwide. See our work.

Get in touch

Tell us about your next project

Share a few details about your business and what you need. We’ll reply with next steps and a time to talk, usually within one working day.

Services Needed